Business Judgment Rule (BJR)
Adams Stirling PLC
Menu

BUSINESS JUDGMENT RULE (BJR)

Legal Issues Security
Neighbor Disputes
HOA Attorneys Board Liability Protection Business Judgment Rule
IDR ADR Attorneys' Fees
Harassment Small Claims Court Artificial Intelligence

Business Judgment Rule (BJR)


Business Judgment Rule & Judicial DeferenceAlthough officers and directors are fiduciaries, boards are not required to make the “right” decision. Instead, they must make what they believe is the best decision for the corporation based on the information available. The Business Judgment Rule (Corp. Code § 7231) protects directors from personal liability if they make decisions that result in damage or loss to others, provided their decisions were made:

  • In Good Faith. The business judgment rule immunizes directors from good faith mistakes in judgment. Barnes v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., (1993) 16 Cal.App.4th 365, 378); To rebut good faith, plaintiff must point to specific evidence establishing a director’s conscious doing of a wrong because of a dishonest purpose or moral obliquity, furtive design or ill will. (Pugh v. See’s Candies, Inc. (1988) 203 Cal.App.3d 743, 763-764)
     
  • Best Interests. Directors must believe their decision is in the association's best interests.
     
  • Reasonable Inquiry. Directors must make their decisions with such care, including reasonable inquiry, as an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances. (Before making decisions, boards may rely on the advice of persons they believe to be reliable and competent in the matters being presented. (Corp. Code § 7231(b)) The phrase “in a like position" means the court will look at industry standards for volunteer homeowner association directors rather than paid professional directors. Professional directors are held to a higher standard. (See Parth Statement of Decision in the remanded case) "Permitting directors to remain ignorant and to rely on their uninformed beliefs to obtain summary judgment would gut the reasonable diligence element of the rule and, quite possibly, incentivize directors to remain ignorant.” (Palm Springs Villas II HOA v. Parth (2016) 248 Cal.App.4th 268)

The BJR creates a presumption that directors’ decisions are based on sound business judgment. This presumption can be rebutted only by a factual showing of fraud, bad faith, or gross overreaching. (Ritter & Ritter v. The Churchill (2008) 166 Cal.App.4th 103, 123) Corporate directors are presumed to have acted in good faith, on an informed basis, and in the honest belief that the action taken was in the corporation's best interest. (Katz v. Chevron Corp. (1994) 22 Cal.App.4th 1352, 1366)

  • BJR protections apply to more than just maintenance and repair decisions. The deferential standard also extends broadly to general board and architectural decisions. The court said the business judgment rule, on which Lamden was modeled, creates a presumption that directors' decisions are made in good faith and are based on sound business judgment. (Eng v. Opperman)

  • For the business judgment rule to apply, boards must actually make a decision. Inaction is not protected. (In re Walt Disney Co. Derivative Litig (Del Ch 2005) 907 A.2d 693) Weighing the facts and consciously deciding to take no action is protected. A decision to refrain from action is different from inaction. An association is not shielded from liability if directors ignore problems. (Affan v. Portofino Cove)
  • Boards can weigh the gravity of a rules violation and the likely outcome of litigation, make a good-faith determination not to litigate a particular violation, and have that decision protected. (Beehan v. Lido Isle)
     
  • A director acting with a material conflict of interest is not protected from personal liability by the business judgment rule. (Coley v. Eskaton)
  • [T]he business judgment rule protects well-meaning directors who are misinformed, misguided, and honestly mistaken. [Directors are] protected by the business judgment rule unless they knew their acts were illegal or they “knowingly committed acts outside the scope of their authority.” (Biren v. Equality Emergency Medical Group, Inc. (2002) 102 Cal.App.4th 125, 137)
     
  • [T]he presumption created by the business judgment rule can be rebutted only by affirmative allegations of facts which, if proven, would establish fraud, bad faith, overreaching, or an unreasonable failure to investigate material facts. (Lauckhart v. El Macero Homeowners Assn. (2023) 92 Cal.App.5th 889, 906)

Additional Liability Protections


For additional protections for HOA volunteers, see "Protecting Volunteers from Liability."

Judicial Deference 


A doctrine related to the Business Judgment Rule is the Rule of Judicial Deference. See "Judicial Deference in HOAs." 

ASSISTANCE: Associations needing legal assistance can contact us. To stay current with community association issues, subscribe to the Davis-Stirling Newsletter.

Adams Stirling PLC