Deed Restricted Non-CID Developments
Property developments can be deed-restricted without being a common interest development (CID). Many single-family developments built from the 1950s through the 1970s had deed restrictions but were not CIDs. They lacked common areas and reciprocal easements, which are required for a development to meet the definition of a CID. (Civ. Code § 4201; Civ. Code § 4095) Some continue to be built, but fewer than true common interest developments.
Preserve Property Values. The developer aimed to preserve property values by regulating paint colors, parking, architectural styles, views, and similar matters. CC&Rs were recorded against all the lots, but instead of creating an association, the developer created an architectural committee, sometimes referred to as an Art Jury, to enforce the restrictions in the community.
Voluntary Association. Non-CID developments often incorporate to establish an association with voluntary membership and dues.
Enforcement Problems. The problem with not creating an association was enforcing the rules. Without an association with automatic membership and mandatory dues, the architectural committee had to raise legal expenses through voluntary donations. As a result, many deed-restricted communities formed voluntary associations with voluntary dues to fund these purposes. Enforcement remains a problem for these communities because litigation is expensive. As a result, some amend the documents and add common area to become a CID. Others gradually stop enforcing their restrictions.
Recreational Property Ownership. Another non-CID form of shared ownership appears in recreational properties such as "R-Ranches" and "R-Wild Horse Ranches," which allow owners access to horseback riding, fishing, hunting, archery, hiking, campgrounds, a lodge, etc. The facilities often provide cabins that owners can reserve for short stays. Owners pay an annual assessment that covers the cost of running the ranch and maintaining the amenities. These recreational associations do not fall under the Davis-Stirling Act because owners have no right to occupy a lot exclusive to them. Typically, the property is not subdivided into lots. The ranch consists of a single large property that may cover thousands of acres. Membership in the association is obtained by purchasing shares of stock in the corporation that owns the property.
ASSISTANCE: Associations needing legal assistance can contact us. To stay current with community association issues, subscribe to the Davis-Stirling Newsletter.